![]() |
|
Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - Printable Version +- Dead Letters (https://deadletters.nyc/forum) +-- Forum: Mailroom (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Discourse & Gossip (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts (/showthread.php?tid=36) Pages:
1
2
|
Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - jared - 10-25-2026 Hello, friends. I wrote a short blog post, and I hope you'll suffer me mentioning it here. It resonates with some of the "game as emergent property of play" discussion we had around here in the recent past, and feels in line with a lot of what our boys talk about (like in the "Against Procedurality" episode, for instance). It's just the first part, something of an introductory piece, before the next part(s), where I intend to provide some concrete examples, both positive and negative, of each of ethos, pathos, and logos deployed as persuasive techniques in various game books. If you have any suggestions for texts I should look into on that front, do let me know. I have some ideas, but I'm always interested in finding better examples. Thanks! RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - udupi - 10-27-2026 Hi Jared, interesting read, thanks for sharing! I had a thought that I reckon might merit further discussion, though, and I would be interested to hear your opinion. You've picked a very folkish game as your example, and I think this muddies the waters somewhat. One could argue that a codified ruleset of Hide and Seek is actually making two arguments at once: (1) You should play the version of Hide and Seek codified in these rules. (2) This ruleset captures the essential features of Hide and Seek and could be used to tell you whether a particular game is Hide and Seek or not. Since Hide and Seek is very diverse in how it's played across the world, making claim (2) is much more difficult, and so the article (and the reader's attention) naturally focuses on claim (1). But I don't think that's true of all games. The International Football Association Board's Laws of the Game focus almost exclusively on claim (2), even stating in the preface: Quote:Football is the greatest sport on earth. It is played on every continent, in every I don't think the IFAB is trying to sell you on its particular rules, so much as it's trying to sell the idea that football is One Thing. So in football's case, you could definitely make the claim that while the book is not the game, it defines the game in some essential way. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - misha - 10-28-2026 That's true, although I think a lot of the value for a codified ruleset for football comes from the way it lets teams from different regions play against each other in the same way that they play at home. How useful that is depends a lot on the type of game; for Hide and Seek it's not a big deal at all, since the rules are so simple and easy to explain. The question is how useful that is for a TTRPG--which I think is something different people would disagree on. I lean towards standardization not being all that useful a goal, but there are definitely big swathes of 5e players who stick to playing exclusively 5e largely so they don't need to spend time and effort memorizing more rules. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - jared - 10-29-2026 (10-27-2026, 04:17 PM)udupi Wrote: Hi Jared, interesting read, thanks for sharing! I had a thought that I reckon might merit further discussion, though, and I would be interested to hear your opinion. Nah, not at all. Because if we, you and I, wanted to play football, we could. And we could decide to play differently than the IFAB would have us play—as humans did for presumably some hundreds of years before the IFAB even existed, and continue to do today despite any claims the IFAB may make to the contrary—and it would still be football. In the passage you quoted, the IFAB is actually bringing their significant ethos to bear, and with some intensely pathetic (in the technical sense) language to boot, in an effort specifically to argue for the version of football they're describing. If, in making that argument, they further posit that football is One Thing, as you point out, they do so because it strengthens their case that we should play by their rules: if we assent to their claim that football is One Thing, then we probably also assent that they have described it, and logically we should therefore play as they have described or risk playing some non-football thing instead. Of course the truth is we'd just be playing one of the infinitely many possible footballs, as people often do. This is, incidentally, an implicit use of logos. A really remarkable and clear example of what I'm talking about in the post, thanks for sharing it! RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - Randalf the Gray - 10-29-2026 As was explored in our previous discussion, this seems like an issue of terminology rather than ontology. No "game" can ever be "the same game" as any other, no matter how similar they are described or formalized. Even a Groundhog's Day-style scenario where a causal loop forced the replaying of a specific game would not allow it to be "the same game", due to the simple ramifications of awareness of a previous iteration of that game. A professional bout of 'football' and a children's game of 'kick the ball' are functionally identical insofar as they can both be described using the same terms without resorting to specifics of rules, set and setting, or any other restrictions on play. That I can describe the antics of Michael Myers or Jason Vorhees as "deadly hide and seek" means that it is a useful enough term to describe a wide variety of behaviors that follow a similar pattern. Qualifying and clarifying terminology can append further specifics as necessary, such as "professional football", which is distinct from any iteration of "non-professional football". What makes a term useful or not is largely up to preference, but over time the collective preference enforces a de facto jargon of some sort, which makes the use of differing terminology more and more prohibitive, and less and less useful as a means to communicate. But jargon requires a certain leniency. It has to be allowed to develop naturally. And so long as it is more or less "organic" in its adoption and growth, it can remain useful, but attempts to restrict terminology to hyper-specific and fixed definitions results in a similar inability to express meaning effectively as if a different term had been used entirely. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - jared - 10-29-2026 (10-29-2026, 02:54 AM)Randalf the Gray Wrote: As was explored in our previous discussion, this seems like an issue of terminology rather than ontology. No "game" can ever be "the same game" as any other, no matter how similar they are described or formalized. Even a Groundhog's Day-style scenario where a causal loop forced the replaying of a specific game would not allow it to be "the same game", due to the simple ramifications of awareness of a previous iteration of that game. Yep! This post is an attempt to treat game texts precisely as rhetorical objects, being that's what they are, as you point out. Every text (every utterance!) is ultimately stepping into the negotiated terministic reality and making some case for a particular version of what should be and how and why. This bit (this time anyway) is very much not any kind of ontology claim, except insofar as to point out that basically any claim about what does and doesn't qualify as a particular game reveals itself to be rhetoric when we acknowledge the absurdity of it. All taxonomical and definitional claims ultimately fall prey to No True Scotsman when you look under the hood. Importantly, this isn't a condemnation of the practice, it's an admission that this is how we make meaning together. And game texts aren't immune. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - misha - 10-29-2026 (10-29-2026, 02:54 AM)Randalf the Gray Wrote: A professional bout of 'football' and a children's game of 'kick the ball' are functionally identical insofar as they can both be described using the same terms without resorting to specifics of rules, set and setting, or any other restrictions on play. This is one valid way of describing it, but what I find even more useful is an autopoietic approach; looking at how the pattern of play repeats and sustains itself. Instead of trying to draw a line around different types of football after the fact, looking at the network of actions that keep different bouts of play looking like each other despite being technically unique instances. That's part of what's really interesting to me about the IFAB definition, it's clearly (as Jared says) a rhetorical device--it's meant to steer 'football' in a certain direction and tighten the cloud of football games to more closely resemble each other. It makes a lot of sense to me that you could look at any given TTRPG book the same way. The question, then, is what the benefits and costs of that type of control are. For football, having most people playing with very similar rules is great for letting people play with new groups as frictionlessly as possible, but surrendering the definition to a top-down regulatory body consolidates power in a way that can get super ugly (actually, I have no idea how corrupt the IFAB is--maybe it just looks bad because of FIFA). And then same with TTRPG books--books are rhetorical devices enticing you to play a certain way. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - Randalf the Gray - 10-29-2026 Quote:Misha: Instead of trying to draw a line around different types of football after the fact, looking at the network of actions that keep different bouts of play looking like each other despite being technically unique instances. It seems these are two approaches to the same end. One, the autopoietic approach you describe, is more methodical, and perhaps ultimately more accurate or specific, but the other is more expedient. Whichever may be more or less useful depends on the needs and context of their use. This reminds me of the fact that Zachery Renauldo (aka ZachTheBold) semi-satirically refers to all non-D&D TRPGs as "D&D-likes". While technically accurate and useful in certain contexts, especially among his audience, the lack of qualifying specificity makes it a mostly useless term to anyone operating outside that sphere. But does the notion of validity, as it applies to terminology, necessitate a "burden of proof" on the terminology itself? To what extent must a term be self-justifying to be accepted as useful? If the autopoietic approach is ultimately favored, wouldn't that diminish the notion of a rhetorical device such as a game book being useful? Wouldn't a non-rhetorical approach be more useful, which in this case might look like exposure to iterations of the game itself, from which the rules are then extrapolated? It seems this is often the more naturalistic way we learn games, through participation. Instead of being told the rules of football by reading a book, we play or watch football until our "sense" of the rules matches the sense of those around us. This extends to TRPGs as well, as many learn to play not through texts but through play itself, either enacted or observed. To be clear, I agree with you, Jared and Misha, about the rhetorical and textual nature of game books. These are just the questions that crop up in my brain. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - jared - 10-30-2026 (10-29-2026, 11:01 PM)Randalf the Gray Wrote: It seems this is often the more naturalistic way we learn games, through participation. Instead of being told the rules of football by reading a book, we play or watch football until our "sense" of the rules matches the sense of those around us. This extends to TRPGs as well, as many learn to play not through texts but through play itself, either enacted or observed. Yeah absolutely, but I wouldn't describe this process as "non-rhetorical" at all. On the contrary, by presenting an instance (or set of instances) of play as representative of "correct" play, we are creating a rhetorical framework for understanding play. (And, incidentally, I'd characterize this process as based in ethos-building, insofar as it places personal experience as precisely the practical factor in advocating for a particular kind of play.) This is already a thing that some game books do, obliquely at least, in the form of "examples of play," which can have myriad purposes but this is decidedly one imo. Ultimately, I'm not of the opinion that there is a non-rhetorical dimension possible where human meaning-making is concerned. But that's maybe its own can of worms. RE: Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts - udupi - 10-30-2026 Thanks Jared, Randalf and Misha for the thought-provoking points you've raised. I accept that the IFAB's preface to their rules is very heavily rhetorical, but I think we disagree on what goal the rhetoric serves. The preface is not a defence of the specific rules of Association Football,¹ but rather a defence of the IFAB (as Misha puts it) 'tighten[ing] the cloud of football games' which can be played. While a cynic might argue this is simply the IFAB cementing the authority of their rules (and therefore cementing their power over the sport), I think they're making a fascinating ontological claim: one of the essential properties of football (as we understand the game today) is its universality, its ability to be the 'World's Game.' In other words, if we lived in an alternate universe where every town and village had their own rules for football, a hypothetical town which by coincidence ended up with the modern Association Football rules still wouldn't be 'playing the same game'.² And, as strange as their claim sounds, I think I agree with the IFAB here. There are many games where the broader culture surrounding the game strongly affects the experience of play. The Reddit April Fool's day games are frequently examples of this, where follow-up websites replicating the rules and mechanics often fail to recreate the experience of playing the original. Although I don't know much about it, from the way the internet talks about Sam's Over/Under game, it feels like it may fall into this category too. ¹ I also disagree that any such defence is necessarily rhetorical. You could investigate a claim like 'The rules of Association Football are more fun than the Cambridge Rules' through a non-rhetorical lens, e.g. a sociological lens might involve observing many games of each and interviewing players on their experiences (or giving them wearable EEGs while they played, or putting them in an MRI machine and asking them to think about their experiences of each game), while a historical lens could examine play reports of Cambridge Rules football tournaments etc. Of course, that's not to say that such investigations can't be used to make rhetorical arguments; I'm simply saying they aren't only useful rhetorically. ² Randalf provided a good critique of the idea of 'playing the same game,' which I agree is at the heart of this matter. The more precise claim here is that the fame of the sport fundamentally changes the experience of play. It's why many people play football wearing shirts with Lionel Messi's name and number on the back, and why they run around trying to whip up cheers from an imaginary crowd after scoring a goal during the school lunchtime game. It would feel like (and therefore be) a totally different game if your village were the only place this game existed. |