Dead Letters
Moves that Grow the Game - Printable Version

+- Dead Letters (https://deadletters.nyc/forum)
+-- Forum: Mailroom (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: RPG Discussion (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Thread: Moves that Grow the Game (/showthread.php?tid=46)



Moves that Grow the Game - shy_owl - 10-28-2026

A cool thing happened in my home OD&D game last session. We were trying to gather the party together, and I was sure one of the player characters (Myrtle Stupendous) had signed a 3-month contract with a henchman. When I went digging for it I found the contract, but to my horror I realized it belonged to Scout Mcphee, a character who had perished, as a henchman, the session previously.

I did some more digging and discovered that Scout Mcphee had *also* signed a 3-month contract with Discretion Limor. Both contracts had Windy Silverfox signed on as guarantor, a person designated to pay life insurance to the families of any hirelings or henchmen that die. All three, Scout, Discretion, and Windy, perished in the dungeon.

But now Myrtle might be in trouble; she is technically liable to pay out 100 gold pieces to the family of Scout Mcphee, even though it was Scout who broke the Seasonal Service Agreement by signing on with Discretion behind Myrtle's back. There's a scheduled time for a town session next month, and I think I'm going to have the family sue Myrtle and we can do a little bit of civil procedure with lawyers and such.

Really exciting turn of events. It reveals something diegetic and character-ful about the Scout Mcphee posthumously. It also tests the utility of the contract system I've set up, and explores a theme I've been meaning to explore in that game about player-character community obligations. It's allowed the game to grow into something bigger.

However, the was it happened was completely player/referee error, entirely an accident. My papers got shuffled around, and nobody realized that Scout was bound by another contract. As referee I would not have allowed Scout to do that if I had seen it.

All the same, when it was revealed, there was never any doubt at the table as to whether in the fiction Scout Mcphee actually signed both. The play error did not need to be corrected. In fact, it turned out not to be an error at all, but a valid move.

I'm really interested in moments where play kind of produces itself like this, to the surprise of everyone. I guess this is just was roleplaying is, what shared fiction looks like, but paperwork is a fun site for that to take place.