Dead Letters
Fictional modern day settings? - Printable Version

+- Dead Letters (https://deadletters.nyc/forum)
+-- Forum: Mailroom (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: RPG Discussion (https://deadletters.nyc/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Thread: Fictional modern day settings? (/showthread.php?tid=76)



Fictional modern day settings? - Dr_Colossus - 11-20-2026

I've been working on an espionage game (which was spawned from an internal argument I was having with the hosts of the podcast), which I had intended to set in the real world, modern day.

This is a pretty common thing for a lot of spy fiction, and a lot of spy TV shows and movies.  Maybe the characters work for a fictional agency.  Maybe a fictional president shows up.  But the 'setting' is basically the real world; the characters live in real places, are acting on behalf of real countries, they will reference real historical events. 

I had received the advice, after showing an early draft, that I should add in some sort of genre element to give the game a unique hook.  Additionally, settings can be copyrighted where game mechanics can't be, a game set in the real world may ignite real conflicts between players in a way that a game in a more fictional setting might not.

I get these arguments, but also think that this works well for the genre in other media; why not in a TTRPG?  I like the idea of it being set in a lightly fictionalized real world because it removes so much of the need to explain things to new players; they already have a strong idea of the setting, how it works, what their characters can do in a way you don't get in say, a fantasy or sci-fi rpg.  Yet, I don't really know of any other games that are set in the real world without the addition of some fantastical elements, so perhaps there's more to this than I'm giving it credit for.  What do you all think of how the idea of a fictional setting works in a modern world game?


RE: Fictional modern day settings? - misha - 11-20-2026

I do think it is a little weird how few non-storygame RPGs there taking place in a non-fantastical modern-day setting; I have a few crackpot theories on why it might be, but all of them ring a little hollow to me. The real world is something people are intimately familiar with (or, worse, is full of elements that only half of the table is intimately familiar with), which creates this dynamic where people expect a lot of fidelity in a way that can easily both create gameplay blockages ("that's not the type of safe that Waffle Houses use to hold their cash") and potentially an urge for overly complicated sim mechanics (although new simulationism-style adjudicative simulation can get around that). People also lean a lot on existing mechanical structures, and half the rules in a game being about how handguns do 1d6 damage feels really at odds with the tone you'd expect from a lot of modern day games, even/especially ones like espionage where gunfights are a constant possibility.

Ultimately, though, I feel like this is all overcomeable and there's a lot of untapped potential in games exactly like you're describing. I think you're on a great path.

Oh, and the copyright thing is silly. I don't know what to say about it past that, really. If you plan on ultimately publishing this, the hook would be in the scenario itself. If you aren't, then there's zero reason to think about copyright in the first place.

(11-20-2026, 03:51 AM)Dr_Colossus Wrote: (which was spawned from an internal argument I was having with the hosts of the podcast)

You love to hear it


RE: Fictional modern day settings? - Dr_Colossus - 11-20-2026

Thanks! I agree, it seems like an underutilized design space, and I was worried that there was some very good reason for that that I hadn't thought through yet. The arguments about people's real life expertise often comes up in my games anyways even with genre elements, in games like Delta Green, or like when I used to play D&D with an archaeologist.

I do plan to publish it when it's done, though game design is just a hobby for me that I started as a way to have something fun and distracting to do on my phone whenever I would otherwise be tempted to doomscroll.

The internal argument was, I think, mostly with your illustrious co-hosts, if I remember correctly. I was listening to the Pendragon episode, where you were discussing the Traits. I love this mechanic and had been thinking a lot about how to implement it in a different game that I was tinkering on, with no success; it did not fit that game.

IIRC, one of your co-hosts (I think) suggested that the Traits would be better if there was some way to override them. I disagreed. I think the beauty of the traits is the way that they push you towards the romance and tragedy that is such a part of Arthurian stories. The game is, to me at least, about exploring the struggle between what you want to do and what you should do. The confines of an oath of conduct our to the test in the world. These stories are all about tragedies that come about because someone can't overcome their nature, or someone managing to do something incredible in spite of that. The way the traits force you to grapple with that, especially when it's really inconvenient, is what makes them so compelling as a mechanic.

Anyways, I started to think, "whats a type of story where it would work for you to be able to override traits?" Which, to me, is classic spy story stuff. With that, it was a real opening the floodgates, where I could see the whole game and just needed to write it down. It's not done, but it's about the fastest I've ever written anything, and is shaping up to be about 1/2 Delta Green, 3/5s Pendragon, 2/5 Blades in the Dark, tossed in a blender and garnished with some Nights Black Agents. Definately the most productive parasocial argument I've engaged in.


RE: Fictional modern day settings? - sam_the_bold - 11-20-2026

We love a productive parasocial argument, hehehe.

I think real-world settings have tremendous value!! I can think of a number of rulebooks that provide rules for real or otherwise non-fantastical/supernatural settings set in our world—many of Jason Morningstar's projects, for example—though I admit that nearly all of them are historical, rather than contemporary. Likewise, whether or not those truly count as escaping "genre" I think is a different question. As it seems like you've landed on, there are plenty of genre works that are still set in our own contemporary world without any supernatural elements: Mission Impossible, say. 

But it sounds cool! Spy games I think can be very tricky to pull of well since the playspace is so vast, but particularly paired with well-designed adventures I could imagine a campaign being fantastic.


RE: Fictional modern day settings? - Dr_Colossus - 11-20-2026

There are definitely more historical ones. Which, now that I think of it, may relate to one of the reasons there aren't so many games set "today"; it's a way of freezing the setting so that the rules stay appropriate to it. That is, in five years, people won't read the rules and wonder why it doesn't have a section on how to use a type of technology that doesn't currently exist, for example. I don't have anything in there about AI, for instance, which wouldn't have even occurred to me if I was writing it 3 years ago, and may be a bigger deal 3 years from now in ways that I can't anticipate that might make the game feel dated to someone finding the game then. Whereas, Victorian London or 1920s New England are what they are and won't change significantly.