10-25-2026, 01:33 AM
I enjoyed this episode quite a bit-- it was a cool change of pace to focus on an old, obscure module.
I've only played one tournament scenario, Tom Mecredy's He Ain't Gonna Jump No More, which I ran on four separate sessions. The feeling I came away with resonates pretty closely with the direction the conversation took -- it's almost impossible to adjudicate competitive RPGs fairly (unlike football or Super Mario 64 speedruns). However, having the "pre-lusory goal" made for a very unique, fun experience. In the case of this module, it worked to create the feeling of being paratroopers on D-Day: under high pressure to complete objectives but granted considerable initiative. In general think the scoring works best as a kind of kayfabe -- everyone knows it's meaningless, but if you treat it like it's meaningful anyway certain possibilities open up.
Re: the pregen discussion, I wonder how hard it would be to write add-on modules that take an existing, detailed module (say Wolves), and provide a set of embedded pregens and small modifications to the world relating to the players' connections. (I don't know Wolves lore that well but say the players are the deposed queen of Albann and her entourage, and the campaign would focus on reclaiming the throne). Alternately, I wonder how common it is to have players take on NPCs in a module -- Keep on The Borderlands, but you play as the Castellan and the Bailiff and the Priest.
Last, I would put forward Gromb's module Mandog (which Sam edited) as a good example of a module built around a strong goal (stop Mandog from immanentizing the eschaton). Also Arnold K's Lair of The Lamb (escape the dungeon).
I've only played one tournament scenario, Tom Mecredy's He Ain't Gonna Jump No More, which I ran on four separate sessions. The feeling I came away with resonates pretty closely with the direction the conversation took -- it's almost impossible to adjudicate competitive RPGs fairly (unlike football or Super Mario 64 speedruns). However, having the "pre-lusory goal" made for a very unique, fun experience. In the case of this module, it worked to create the feeling of being paratroopers on D-Day: under high pressure to complete objectives but granted considerable initiative. In general think the scoring works best as a kind of kayfabe -- everyone knows it's meaningless, but if you treat it like it's meaningful anyway certain possibilities open up.
Re: the pregen discussion, I wonder how hard it would be to write add-on modules that take an existing, detailed module (say Wolves), and provide a set of embedded pregens and small modifications to the world relating to the players' connections. (I don't know Wolves lore that well but say the players are the deposed queen of Albann and her entourage, and the campaign would focus on reclaiming the throne). Alternately, I wonder how common it is to have players take on NPCs in a module -- Keep on The Borderlands, but you play as the Castellan and the Bailiff and the Priest.
Last, I would put forward Gromb's module Mandog (which Sam edited) as a good example of a module built around a strong goal (stop Mandog from immanentizing the eschaton). Also Arnold K's Lair of The Lamb (escape the dungeon).

