10-27-2026, 04:17 PM
Hi Jared, interesting read, thanks for sharing! I had a thought that I reckon might merit further discussion, though, and I would be interested to hear your opinion.
You've picked a very folkish game as your example, and I think this muddies the waters somewhat. One could argue that a codified ruleset of Hide and Seek is actually making two arguments at once:
(1) You should play the version of Hide and Seek codified in these rules.
(2) This ruleset captures the essential features of Hide and Seek and could be used to tell you whether a particular game is Hide and Seek or not.
Since Hide and Seek is very diverse in how it's played across the world, making claim (2) is much more difficult, and so the article (and the reader's attention) naturally focuses on claim (1). But I don't think that's true of all games. The International Football Association Board's Laws of the Game focus almost exclusively on claim (2), even stating in the preface:
I don't think the IFAB is trying to sell you on its particular rules, so much as it's trying to sell the idea that football is One Thing. So in football's case, you could definitely make the claim that while the book is not the game, it defines the game in some essential way.
You've picked a very folkish game as your example, and I think this muddies the waters somewhat. One could argue that a codified ruleset of Hide and Seek is actually making two arguments at once:
(1) You should play the version of Hide and Seek codified in these rules.
(2) This ruleset captures the essential features of Hide and Seek and could be used to tell you whether a particular game is Hide and Seek or not.
Since Hide and Seek is very diverse in how it's played across the world, making claim (2) is much more difficult, and so the article (and the reader's attention) naturally focuses on claim (1). But I don't think that's true of all games. The International Football Association Board's Laws of the Game focus almost exclusively on claim (2), even stating in the preface:
Quote:Football is the greatest sport on earth. It is played on every continent, in every
country and at many different levels. The fact that the Laws of the Game are the
same for all football throughout the world, from the FIFA World Cup™ through
to a game between young children in a remote village, is a considerable
strength which must continue to be harnessed for the good of football
everywhere.
I don't think the IFAB is trying to sell you on its particular rules, so much as it's trying to sell the idea that football is One Thing. So in football's case, you could definitely make the claim that while the book is not the game, it defines the game in some essential way.

