10-29-2026, 11:39 AM
(10-29-2026, 02:54 AM)Randalf the Gray Wrote: As was explored in our previous discussion, this seems like an issue of terminology rather than ontology. No "game" can ever be "the same game" as any other, no matter how similar they are described or formalized. Even a Groundhog's Day-style scenario where a causal loop forced the replaying of a specific game would not allow it to be "the same game", due to the simple ramifications of awareness of a previous iteration of that game.
A professional bout of 'football' and a children's game of 'kick the ball' are functionally identical insofar as they can both be described using the same terms without resorting to specifics of rules, set and setting, or any other restrictions on play.
That I can describe the antics of Michael Myers or Jason Vorhees as "deadly hide and seek" means that it is a useful enough term to describe a wide variety of behaviors that follow a similar pattern. Qualifying and clarifying terminology can append further specifics as necessary, such as "professional football", which is distinct from any iteration of "non-professional football".
What makes a term useful or not is largely up to preference, but over time the collective preference enforces a de facto jargon of some sort, which makes the use of differing terminology more and more prohibitive, and less and less useful as a means to communicate.
But jargon requires a certain leniency. It has to be allowed to develop naturally. And so long as it is more or less "organic" in its adoption and growth, it can remain useful, but attempts to restrict terminology to hyper-specific and fixed definitions results in a similar inability to express meaning effectively as if a different term had been used entirely.
Yep! This post is an attempt to treat game texts precisely as rhetorical objects, being that's what they are, as you point out. Every text (every utterance!) is ultimately stepping into the negotiated terministic reality and making some case for a particular version of what should be and how and why. This bit (this time anyway) is very much not any kind of ontology claim, except insofar as to point out that basically any claim about what does and doesn't qualify as a particular game reveals itself to be rhetoric when we acknowledge the absurdity of it. All taxonomical and definitional claims ultimately fall prey to No True Scotsman when you look under the hood. Importantly, this isn't a condemnation of the practice, it's an admission that this is how we make meaning together. And game texts aren't immune.
Love,
Jared
Jared

